BLOG TO COMM

BOOK(S) REVIEW! MUTT & JEFF GIANT-SIZE STANDARD COLOR EDITION, VOLS. ONE AND THREE (Retro Comic Reprints)

Hardly a man is now alive who can remember when MUTT & JEFF was hotcha potatoes in the world of newspaper comic stripdom. Beginning in 1907, this once-all over the place cartoon had the distinction of being the first (or at least one of 'em) to appear on weekdays, and at one time you just couldn't escape the thing what with animated films and products based on the strip permeating just about every aspect of one's life the way PEANUTS would forty years later. This comic even affected various other realms of life---f'r example "Mutt and Jeff" became a common police term to describe a pair of suspects with drastically opposite features. Creator Bud Fisher was also one of the first celebrity comic strip artists even if, for the most part, the guy hired out all his work as time went on but eh, he sure coulda afforded it given the dinero being raked in!

As anyone would prob'ly expect MUTT & JEFF eventually fizzed out as time went on, and during its final days it became a daily groaner for many a comic strip hound on the search for a good badgag. In no way could the thing survive in today's comic strip world --- had it somehow lived on it would have gone through, like NANCY, some heavy "updates" that would have made it agonizingly unrecognizable from the original form. But then again, had it lasted into the present day perhaps the public would have protested loudly to any slight change in style in the same fashion that fans got into an uproar when the news that the BLONDIE strip was gonna creep into the present day what with new decor, hairstyles and even a spiffy new suit for Dagwood --- now THAT was something for one to grab the pitchforks and get riled up about if you ask me!

One interesting thing about MUTT & JEFF was that for quite a spell the two were part of Max Gaines' All American branch of the DC publishing empire. Yes, before they headed out for the somewhat less green pastures of Harvey Comics the duo's old newspaper strips were being recycled for perhaps thee premier comics line of the day and sheesh, at times you could see the two of 'em on some comic book cover appearing right next to such luminaries as the Flash and Green Lantern which I gotta admit does give 'em some class, at least by association. Unfortunately they had about as much of a chance to join up with the Justice Society of America the same way that Dennis the Menace had joining the Avengers during his brief stint at Marvel, But sheesh, the thought of it does make for a kinda/sorta funny brief moment in this agony we call life now, doesn't it?

And yet another comic book publisher of past triumphs, namely, Retro Comic Reprints, have gathered these now PD titles for present day consumption, volumes one and three which were graciously zoomed my way by none other than Bill Shute.

Not being too familiar with MUTT & JEFF other'n when I would pour through old comic histories, out of town newspapers or especially MAD spoofs, I will admit that this pair of books were a refreshing high dive to the strip. And after all of these comics presented to me in overdose fashion I will admit that MUTT & JEFF was a groaner true, but a groaner in a good way when a bad gag is needed in one's life just to give it a break from the mundaneness of sophistication and class. Like I said over and over again, bad gags can be done up right as they often were in the Bob Montana-era ARCHIE strips or they could flop about as a cursory look into any cheap comedy-oriented title of the fifties will attest to. 

The jokes you see in MUTT & JEFF work out like --- OK. Some of them hit you right in the funnybone while others miss by a mile, but that don't always matter because the artwork is grand in that old style where it seemed as if the artists had some sort of craft about themselves and bothered to add things like detail and style into their work. Things that are in quite short supply if my recent glances at the comics page are any indication. Not only that but the characters are well formed, what with Mutt being more of the stupid yet in charge Bud Abbot of the two and Jeff a naive simp worth the punchline you know that he's eventually gonna deliver on.

Also included in these comic books were other efforts related to MUTT & JEFF or not for that matter. Strip "topper" CICERO'S CAT (Cicero just happens to be Mutt's son and rarely even appeared in these strips) rates well with all of the other pussy comics that were appearing at the time and heck, sometimes even Mutt or Jeff show up in these in supporting roles. However, I thought SIMP O'DILL didn't have a thing going for it, coming off like the kind of har har filler you say in more'n just a few Golden Age titles of the forties. Funny thing is, this strip must have been somewhat popular since there was at least one Tijuana Bible featuring the guy.

With all of the original ads and text kept in place, these are a nice bunch of book that are gosh awful handy to have around when the cravings for an antique joke just needs to hit'cha. And hey, MUTT & JEFF was even educational for me because, even after years of reading and collecting 'em, I never knew that for a spell Gaines's All American line had its own logo, a slug with "AA" in the center almost identical to the long-running DC one I'm sure some of you remember from your early comic book scarfing days! When Gaines sold out and started EC the familiar DC logo was finally used on the covers but for the life of me I never did come across an "AA" in my born days! And given how this logo features curved letters aligning themselves to the edge of the inner circle I was reminded that, when I first discovered 'em, I once actually thought that EC comics were part of the DC empire because of the similarity in their ID! (Don Fellman thought I was a stoop for thinking this and given the people he's had to encounter in his life he should know!) Not only that but the inside front covers of the AA and EC books, what with their listing of available titles and "Editorial Advisory" list, are nearly identical (even the print!) which does make for a big "now how about that!" at least in my life!

Of course given the difference 'tween DC/AA and EC regarding content not to mention their cover schemes etc., these companies just weren't alike one iota. But sheesh, given how Gaines manned both AA and EC and the stark similarities in their circle within a circle slug logo perhaps the truth was a heck of a lot whole lot closer to what I had originally thought in my not quite formed twelve-year-old brain! In the "you learn something new every day" department this one really was a biggie!